ClimateFast ClimateVoting Records Toronto

2021.MM36.36

Enhanced Tree Replacement Strategy for Dwight Avenue Sidewalk Installation

More Nature City Council consideration on Oct 4, 2021

Background

A sidewalk installation on Dwight Avenue between Birmingham Street and Maple Street in Ward 3 will result in the removal of twelve trees in the work zone, adjacent to Second Street Junior Middle School. Project staff have explored alternative options, and confirmed that there is no way to accommodate the sidewalk, and maintain the existing trees. There is significant concern among the local community that too many neighbourhood trees are being removed through various building and construction projects.

Ten of the twelve trees are tree species that are no longer being planted due to various impacts such as susceptibility to forest pests, like the Emerald Ash Borer or invasive qualities. As we know, because of these types of pests, it is likely that Ash trees in the City will require removal in the future. While the loss of these trees is significant, there is an opportunity to offset the removal, and bolster our tree canopy by increasing the replanting ratio, and planting healthier trees now.

Source: City of Toronto

Item Description

City Council on October 1 and 4, 2021, adopted the following:

  

1. City Council direct the General Manager, Transportation Services to halt the tree removal of the twelve City-owned trees on Dwight Avenue until such time that staff can study the feasibility of narrowing Dwight Avenue, in an attempt to accommodate the proposed new sidewalk and save the existing trees, and to report back to the December 2, 2021 meeting of the Infrastructure and Environment Committee on the findings.

Source: City of Toronto

Proposed by

Councillor Mark Grimes, seconded by Councillor Mike Colle

Result

Carried
Yes20 No1 Absent5

Votes

Yes
Photo of Paul Ainslie
Councillor
Paul Ainslie
Absent
Photo of Ana Bailão
Former Councillor
Ana Bailão
Absent
Photo of Brad Bradford
Councillor
Brad Bradford
Yes
Photo of Shelley Carroll
Councillor
Shelley Carroll
Yes
Photo of Mike Colle
Councillor
Mike Colle
Yes
Photo of Gary Crawford
Former Councillor
Gary Crawford
Yes
Photo of Joe Cressy
Former Councillor
Joe Cressy
Yes
Photo of John Filion
Former Councillor
John Filion
Absent
Photo of Paula Fletcher
Councillor
Paula Fletcher
Yes
Photo of Michael Ford
Former Councillor
Michael Ford
Yes
Photo of Mark Grimes
Former Councillor
Mark Grimes
No
Photo of Stephen Holyday
Councillor
Stephen Holyday
Yes
Photo of Cynthia Lai
Former Councillor
Cynthia Lai
Yes
Photo of Mike Layton
Former Councillor
Mike Layton
Yes
Photo of Nick Mantas
Councillor
Nick Mantas
Yes
Photo of Josh Matlow
Councillor
Josh Matlow
Yes
Photo of Jennifer McKelvie
Councillor
Jennifer McKelvie
Yes
Photo of Denzil Minnan-Wong
Former Councillor
Denzil Minnan-Wong
Yes
Photo of Frances Nunziata
Councillor
Frances Nunziata
Yes
Photo of James Pasternak
Councillor
James Pasternak
Yes
Photo of Gord Perks
Councillor
Gord Perks
Yes
Photo of Anthony Perruzza
Councillor
Anthony Perruzza
Absent
Photo of Jaye Robinson
Former Councillor
Jaye Robinson
Absent
Photo of Michael Thompson
Councillor
Michael Thompson
Yes
Photo of John Tory
Former Mayor
John Tory
Yes
Photo of Kristyn Wong-Tam
Former Councillor
Kristyn Wong-Tam